Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stephen Schecter's avatar

John Donne also wrote: "Teach me to hear Mermaides singing." I was delighted to read that in a book I found of his selected writings called - yes, you guessed it - No Man is an Island. In it I also read this little poem: "A man may live of a little; but, alas, of how much less may a man die." And then this one too, appropriately on the subject about which you also write: "As all shadows are of one color, if you respect the body from which they are cast, (for our shadows upon clay will be dirty, and in a garden green and flowery) so all retiring into a shadowy life are alike from all causes, and alike subject to the barbarousness and insipid dullness of the Country; only the employments, and that upon which you cast and and bestow your pleasure, business, or books, gives it the tincture, and beauty. But truly wheresoever we are, if we can but tell ourselves truly what and where we would be, we may make any state and place such."

Like you I have been down in the dumps lately and out of sorts, mainly because of the growing slander and menace against our beloved Israel, making me impatient with the Israeli push to conquer Gaza and force the psychopaths there to release the hostages. I now see the out of his depth Witkoff and his boss Trump are pushing for another ceasefire and partial hostage release, not to mention my own Canadian Prime Minister's joining the jackal baying of western European leaders to force Israel's hand to capitulate to suicide. One loses all faith in and sympathy towards the human race, a feeling which is not good for the soul. In today's world there is no island to which to escape; the folly is such that it will reach us even on the beach in the Outer Banks. But that might be a good place to die. Remember On The Beach, the movie they made of Nevile Shute's book with Gregory Peck and Ava Gardner? Even today I can remember seeing it in Montreal, taken there by a favourite uncle along with his daughter, and being impressed by the stark beauty of it all, even with the impending lifeless end. But the world today is so crazy, the moral compass of the people who govern us and elected by us so askew, the much of which we live seems little and even a nuclear cleansing nothing more than just deserts for a species that can't seem to get it. Verily, teach me to hear Mermaides singing. I still don't get it, but thank you for sending me scurrying to my library shelf to reach for my book of John Donne's writings. (Stanyon Books and Random House, 1970, edited by Keith Fallon should you come across it.)

Expand full comment
Charlotte's avatar

I have a similar craving at times only it’s a cabin in the woods. Although an island would suffice I’m sure. For me I think it’s about the fight, flight, freeze impulse - in this case the flight impulse gets activated when people, places and things get too much. Which is a lot at the moment! Surrounded by seemingly insane and ridiculous people and their questionable morals.

Interestingly, I have just spent two weeks in Israel - not a cabin in the woods, or an island - but it sure did soothe the flight impulse. Perhaps it was being around people who get where I’m coming from and who know the meaning of threat and resilience from experience.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts